Topramezone in chickpea: what one two-season trial can and cannot tell you
A single two-season field trial in West Bengal found topramezone at 25 g/ha suppressed chickpea weeds with no visible crop injury.
What the research shows
- In a two-season field trial at Sriniketan, West Bengal, topramezone at 25 g/ha applied 25 days after sowing reduced chickpea weed density and weed dry weight and gave a seed yield of 1402.58 kg/ha. Field trial
- EWRC phytotoxicity scores for all topramezone treatments stayed at 1 across every observation interval, while imazethapyr scored up to 4 at 7 days after application and declined by 30 days. Field trial
- Topramezone at 25 g/ha performed comparably to pendimethalin at 750 g/ha and better than imazethapyr at 60 g/ha in that trial. Field trial
- In kharif maize, topramezone at 25 g/ha applied post-emergence after atrazine or pyroxasulfone equalled the weed-free treatment for dry matter, nutrient uptake and yield. Field trial
- A separate chickpea trial under conservation agriculture at Raipur reported 1740 kg/ha seed yield and 79.42 percent weed control efficiency with hand weeding twice. Field trial
- A nano-encapsulated topramezone formulation showed stronger growth inhibition of the invasive weed Cyclachaena xanthiifolia than free topramezone, and its biosafety testing used fruit flies, S2 cells and maize seeds rather than chickpea. Laboratory studypartially supportedShown under laboratory conditions, not in the field.
Each of these was checked against the abstracts of the papers it cites. See the receipts.
Topramezone in chickpea: what one two-season trial can and cannot tell you
Chickpea has a weed problem and a herbicide problem. The crop establishes slowly, weeds arrive early, and the post-emergence options open to pulses carry a real risk of injuring the crop you are trying to protect. A 2026 field trial at Sriniketan, West Bengal, asked whether topramezone could square that circle [3].
In that field, in those two seasons, it did. Topramezone at 25 g/ha, applied 25 days after sowing, reduced weed density and weed dry weight, produced 1402.58 kg/ha of seed, and scored 1 on the European Weed Research Council phytotoxicity scale at every observation — which the authors describe as no crop injury [3]. It matched pendimethalin at 750 g/ha and beat imazethapyr at 60 g/ha [3]. It is also one trial: a single location, two rabi seasons, nine treatments, three replications, and no unweeded or weed-free control in the abstract against which to read the 1402 kg/ha. Those two missing numbers matter more than the one that is given.
What the trial actually measured
The design is standard: a randomised block with nine treatments and three replications, comparing topramezone across a 15 to 25 g/ha range with two reference herbicides, over 2021–22 and 2022–23 [3]. The measurements were weed density, weed dry weight, EWRC injury scores at several intervals, plant height, leaf area index, dry matter accumulation and seed yield [3].
Note what is not in that list. No weed flora survey, so we do not know which species were suppressed. No soil or residue measurement. No economic return, which matters because herbicide decisions on smallholder pulse crops are usually cost decisions. And no second site.
The safety result
The phytotoxicity data are the most persuasive part of the paper. Every topramezone treatment scored 1 on the EWRC scale, at every observation interval [3]. Imazethapyr, commonly used in pulses, reached 4 at seven days after application before declining by day 30 [3]. That is the difference between a crop that looks untouched and one that visibly yellows and then recovers.
Two cautions. EWRC scoring is visual: a score of 1 records what an observer saw, not what a laboratory would find in the plant's physiology, and visual recovery does not automatically mean yield recovery. The abstract reports the imazethapyr yield figure nowhere, so we cannot tell from it whether the transient injury cost anything. And a low score can be over-read. A score of 1 is reassuring; it is not a claim that the herbicide is inert in chickpea, and this trial tested one application timing — 25 days after sowing [3]. Nothing in the abstract says what happens at 15 days, or 35.
The yield number needs a reference point
1402.58 kg/ha is the headline figure under the 25 g/ha treatment [3]. On its own it does not tell you much, because yield depends on the site's rainfall, soil, sowing date and variety as much as on the herbicide. What you want is the weedy check: how much did the weeds cost if you did nothing? Without it, 1402 kg/ha describes a field, not a treatment effect.
Comparisons across trials do not fill the gap. A separate chickpea experiment under conservation agriculture at Raipur, in rice-residue retention, reported 1740 kg/ha seed yield and 79.42 percent weed control efficiency from hand weeding twice [10]. That is a higher yield than the topramezone trial produced. It would be wrong to conclude anything from the comparison: different site, seasons, cropping system, weed flora, and a completely different intervention. It is a reminder that single-site yield numbers travel badly, not evidence that hand weeding is superior.
What topramezone does inside a plant
This trial measures outcomes — fewer weeds, more seed — not mechanism. The most detailed mechanistic account in the sources here comes from a different study: a nano-encapsulated formulation tested against the invasive weed Cyclachaena xanthiifolia [2]. Treated plants showed reduced chlorophyll and nitrogen content, suppressed photosynthetic electron transport, impaired NADPH generation, redirected carbon allocation and increased jasmonic acid biosynthesis, alongside stronger growth inhibition than free topramezone [2].
Use that carefully. The species is not chickpea, the formulation is not the one used at Sriniketan, and the authors attribute part of the amplified effect to the polymer carrier rather than to topramezone alone [2]. It is a plausible picture of what a topramezone molecule does to a plant. It is not evidence about chickpea.
For background on the chemistry, a 2026 review of isoxazole-derived agrochemicals describes that ring system as a privileged scaffold — rigid, electronically distinctive, heavily modifiable — with several commercial fungicides, insecticides and herbicides built on it, and argues the motif suits low-toxicity, low-residue design [7]. The abstract never mentions topramezone, chickpea, or this trial. It is context, not support.
What the other crops show, and where the analogy breaks
In the sources assembled here, topramezone appears almost entirely in maize. One kharif maize trial found topramezone at 25 g/ha applied post-emergence after atrazine or pyroxasulfone equalled the weed-free treatment for dry matter, nutrient uptake and yield [6]. Even within maize the rankings move: in one comparison a topramezone plus atrazine premix gave the tallest plants and heaviest test weight, but the highest cob yield came from a solo topramezone product [9]; in another, tembotrione took the top grain yield [4].
Timing is worth flagging. In a maize study on itch grass, delaying the post-emergence spray from 12 to 18 or 23 days after sowing increased weed density across every weed group [8]. The chickpea trial sprayed at 25 days [3]. Chickpea is a slower crop than maize, its critical weed-free period differs, and the two systems share neither weed flora nor canopy architecture. So this is a question, not a criticism: whether 25 days is early enough in chickpea is something the trial's own data would answer better than a maize analogy can.
Where the evidence runs out
The single biggest gap is the control. Without a weedy check in the abstract, the yield benefit is unquantified; without a weed-free check, so is the yield still being lost. Both may exist in the full paper. Neither is in the summary, and a reader cannot supply them.
Beyond that:
- One site, two seasons. The authors state the conclusion for chickpea cultivation generally, but the trial covers one farm in West Bengal [3]. Soil, rainfall and weed spectrum elsewhere are untested here.
- No species-level data. "Weed density and dry weight" is a bulk measure. Whether topramezone controls the broadleaf weeds that matter most in chickpea, or only the grasses, is not stated [3].
- Residual effects unknown. Nothing in the abstract addresses carryover to a following crop, the classic concern with low-dose post-emergence herbicides in a rotation.
- No resistance picture. Resistance to herbicides does evolve, and one mechanism now documented in the grass weed Leptochloa chinensis involves suppressing the activation of a proherbicide rather than degrading the active molecule [11]. That is a different herbicide and a different species. It demonstrates the category of risk, nothing about topramezone in chickpea.
- No economics. In a pulse crop, a herbicide that works but does not pay is not adopted.
None of this makes the finding wrong. A replicated two-season field trial showing weed suppression with no visible crop injury at 25 g/ha is a reasonable basis for a larger programme of work. It is not a basis for a recommendation to farmers, and the abstract stops short of the data that would make it one.
References
- [1]Efficacy of post-emergence herbicides on weed dynamics, productivity and economics in spring planted sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum)N KIRAN, J K SINGH, M K SINGH, B SAMUEL NAIK, G PRATHAP REDDY, PRADEEP KUMAR KALWAR · 2026 · The Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciencesdoi:10.56093/ijas.v96i6.171805
- [2]Multilevel synergistic mechanisms of a nanocarrier-enabled topramezone herbicide against invasive weedsJingyi Chen, Heng Qiao, Xiao Ran, Jixing Xia, Hegan Dong, Hanyue Wang · 2026 · Journal of Nanobiotechnologydoi:10.1186/s12951-026-04472-5
- [3]Effect of topramezone herbicide on weed suppression, crop safety and productivity in chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)S R Meka, K Manika, G Pritam, A S Kader, S Guruwaan · 2026 · Plant Science Todaydoi:10.14719/pst.16775
- [4]IMPACT OF POST EMERGENCE HERBICIDES ON WEED DYNAMICS, YIELD AND NUTRIENT UPTAKE OF MAIZE: A COMPARATIVE EVALUATION OF LINEAR AND MACHINE LEARNING APPROACHRayala Srinivasa Rao, B Jambamma,, Danam Sravanthi, I. V. Srinivasa Reddy, · 2026 · The Journal of Animal and Plant Sciencesdoi:10.36899/japs.2027.1.0005
- [5]Effect of weed control practices on nutrient content of maize (Zea Mays L.)Harshita Mishra, HS Kushwaha, Vikas Tiwari, Jyoti Kahar, Ajay Kumar Kashyap · 2026 · International Journal of Research in Agronomydoi:10.33545/2618060x.2026.v9.i10b.6757
- [6]Periodical dry matter, nutrient uptake and yield at harvest of maize affected by application of pre and post emergence herbicidesRS Harale, SD Bhingardeve, PN Gajbhiye, SR Karad, JB Patil, SM Shende · 2026 · International Journal of Advanced Biochemistry Researchdoi:10.33545/26174693.2026.v10.i10sg.10334
- [7]Isoxazole derivatives: Progress and perspectives in agrochemical discoveryTingting Zhang, Qing Li, Yanqun Peng, Deyu Hu, Jian Zhang · 2026 · Advanced Agrochemdoi:10.1016/j.aac.2026.10.001
- [8]Weed flora composition and population dynamics of itch grass (Rottboellia cochinchinensis) and associated weeds in maize as influenced by sequential herbicide programmesHarish Naik T, Narayana S Mavarkar, Suresh Naik KP, Nandish MS, Ganapati ., Kanukula Akhil · 2026 · International Journal of Research in Agronomydoi:10.33545/2618060x.2026.v9.i10m.6918
- [9]Impact of different application of herbicides on growth and yield of hybrid maize (Zea mays L.)Aashutosh Vyasa, Matukdhari Singh, Ajanta Borah · 2026 · International Journal of Research in Agronomydoi:10.33545/2618060x.2026.v9.i10o.6954
- [10]Enhancing chickpea productivity and profitability through improved sowing and weed management practices under conservation agricultureOmprakash Rajwade, RM Savu, Kishan Kumar Sharma, SK Gupta, Khushboo Sharma, Ekta Rajput · 2026 · International Journal of Research in Agronomydoi:10.33545/2618060x.2026.v9.i10q.6992
- [11]LcAKR4C10 confers resistance to tripyrasulfone in Leptochloa chinensis by suppressing proherbicide activation and alleviating oxidative stressJinhui Li, Jiahao Lun, Lianyang Bai, Lang Pan · 2026 · Advanced Agrochemdoi:10.1016/j.aac.2026.09.007
- [12]Weed management in rainfed maize (Zea mays L.) through early post emergent herbicidesMadavi SR, Dongarwar LN, Borkar VH, Kondawar MR · 2026 · International Journal of Advanced Biochemistry Researchdoi:10.33545/26174693.2026.v10.i8su.9697
- [13]Summed dominance ratio-based analysis of weed diversity and dominance in maize fieldsKansa Dianti Putri, Mutmainnah, Kiky Nurfitri Sari, Indriati Meilina Sari, Andika Prawanto · 2026 · Journal of Agrosociology and Sustainabilitydoi:10.61511/jassu.v4i1.2026.3283
- [14]Effect of different weed management practices on weed density, weed dry matter and weed control efficiency in maize (Zea mays L.)Abhinav ., RB Tiwari, Geet Sharma, SK Verma, NK Chaure, Sakshi Dubey · 2026 · International Journal of Advanced Biochemistry Researchdoi:10.33545/26174693.2026.v10.i7sf.9025
All 14 references resolved against Crossref on Nov 13, 2026. Full verification record.
Get the findings, not the noise
A short email when something worth knowing clears the verification gate. No takes. Unsubscribe in one click.